The cheapest way from JFK to Amityville is the train at $18.50 off-peak or $22.00 at peak per person: the $8.75 AirTrain to Jamaica plus a Long Island Rail Road train from Jamaica to Amityville at $9.75 off-peak or $13.25 at peak. The cheapest car is an economy sedan on a written per-trip quote, and no published flat fare prices it: the JFK to Manhattan economy flat of $65 covers Manhattan only. The drive measures 22.1 miles and 33 minutes with no traffic, and the honest comparison is per person: a party of four pays $74 to $88 on the train, before any local ride from Amityville station to the door, against one car quote split four ways. For a solo traveler the train wins outright; for a party of four with luggage, the car often wins on the total.
Picture a traveler who typed “cheapest” into the search box and meant it: not the cheapest advertised number, but the lowest total out of pocket at the end of the trip, including the last mile, the tolls, the tip, and the ride from the station when the train stops short of the door. This page answers that question honestly. It prices the train exactly, builds the car quote ladder without inventing a fare, gives the booking tactics that actually lower the price, and names the trips where the cheapest option costs more than the car. The JFK to Amityville car service page covers the general car service picture for the same run.
Written by Emily Davis · Fact-checked by Alex Freeman, Editor-in-Chief · Last verified November 2026

Good to Know
- Cheapest overall: train at $18.50 off-peak or $22.00 at peak per person
- Cheapest car: economy sedan on a written per-trip quote, no flat fare published
- JFK to Amityville: 22.1 miles, 33 minutes with no traffic
- Party of four on the train: $74 to $88, before the station-to-door ride
- Amityville: village in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, South Shore of Long Island
The cheapest rung: the train, priced exactly
The train journey has two legs. First, ride the AirTrain from the terminal to Jamaica for $8.75. Second, ride a Long Island Rail Road train from Jamaica to Amityville. The Long Island Rail Road fare from Jamaica to Amityville is $9.75 off-peak or $13.25 at peak, because Jamaica sits in Zone 3 and Amityville sits in Zone 9, and the Zone 3 to Zone 9 one-way fare is $9.75 off-peak or $13.25 at peak. The total is $8.75 plus $9.75, which is $18.50 off-peak, or $8.75 plus $13.25, which is $22.00 at peak. Peak means weekday trains arriving at a New York terminal between 6:00 AM and 10:00 AM or leaving between 4:00 PM and 8:00 PM, so a midday arrival travels off-peak and a rush-hour arrival travels at peak. A Long Island Rail Road train from Jamaica reaches Amityville in about 37 minutes, a figure derived from the published Jamaica to Babylon time of 48 minutes minus the Babylon to Amityville time of 11 minutes. The JFK AirTrain cost page carries the AirTrain fare detail.
The train total is per person, and that is the detail that decides the comparison. One traveler pays $18.50 or $22.00. Two travelers pay $37.00 or $44.00. Four travelers pay $74.00 or $88.00. The train also stops at Amityville station, not at the door, so a traveler whose destination is not walking distance from the station needs a local ride for the last mile, and that ride has its own price. Children under 5 ride the AirTrain free, and the train suits a solo traveler with one bag, a traveler with time to spare, and anyone whose destination sits near the station. It does not suit a family with four suitcases arriving late at night, and the section below on when cheapest is not cheapest explains why.
The quote ladder: cheapest car to dearest
No published flat fare covers any car service run from JFK to Amityville, so the ladder below is ordered by rung, not by invented price. Each rung is priced by written per-trip quote confirmed before travel, and the traveler should ask what the quote includes: the tolls, the $3.50 JFK pickup access fee for a for-hire vehicle, and any waiting time. A shared van booked in advance sits below the private car rungs when it runs, and its fare is quoted at booking. The economy sedan is the cheapest private rung. The SUVs cost more and carry more luggage. The van, the Sprinter, and the stretch limousine cost the most and carry the largest parties.
| Option | Price basis | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Train via Jamaica | $18.50 off-peak or $22.00 at peak per person | Solo traveler, light luggage |
| Shared van, pre-booked | Quoted at booking, per person | Solo traveler, flexible schedule |
| Economy sedan, private | Written per-trip quote | One to three travelers, two suitcases |
| SUV, private | Written per-trip quote, higher rung | Family, four suitcases and a stroller |
| Van, Sprinter, or stretch | Written per-trip quote, highest rungs | Groups of six or more |
Hourly hire is separate from fixed route fares, and the rate sheet matters when the trip is hourly rather than a single run. The Economy Sedan is $45 per hour with a 3-hour minimum. The Luxury Sedan is $55 per hour with a 3-hour minimum. The Economy SUV is $72 per hour with a 3-hour minimum. The Luxury SUV is $80 per hour with a 3-hour minimum. The Premium Sedan is $100 per hour with a 3-hour minimum. The Economy Van is $120 per hour with a 4-hour minimum. The Sprinter is $130 per hour with a 4-hour minimum and a $520 floor. The stretch limousine is $144 per hour with a 4-hour minimum and a $576 floor, and stretch limousines seat 6 to 25 passengers. The JetBlack fleet page states each class rate, minimum, and seats, the vehicle types in the car service fleet page describes the classes, and the limo from JFK to Amityville and stretch limo from JFK to Amityville pages cover the top rungs. Child seats cost about $35 per seat for a fee, confirmed at booking, and wheelchair-accessible vehicles are provided.
Booking tactics that actually lower the price
Book ahead. A pre-booked car with a written quote is cheaper than a curbside negotiation, and a quote obtained days ahead can be compared against the train total for the whole party before the flight lands. Share the car: one car quote split across four travelers is usually less per person than four train tickets plus the station-to-door ride, and the comparison should be run on the whole party, not on one person. Travel off-peak when the schedule allows: the train fare drops from $22.00 to $18.50 per person outside peak hours, and the drive avoids the worst of the Southern State Parkway congestion. Confirm the quote in writing with the total, the vehicle class, the tolls, the airport access fee, and the waiting-time terms, and ask whether the tolls are included before accepting it. The page on additional charges for tolls and other expenses explains the toll position. The guide to booking an airport shuttle service for JFK covers the shuttle booking process for travelers weighing the shared option.
Compare the whole journey, not the headline number. The train total of $18.50 excludes the local ride from Amityville station to the door, the car quote excludes the tip unless the quote says otherwise, and gratuity is not included, with a 20 percent tip suggested. A traveler who compares the train fare alone against the car quote alone, without the last mile and without the tip, is comparing two incomplete numbers. Add the last mile to the train side, add the tip to the car side, and the honest comparison appears. Cancellation is free before confirmation; cancelling after confirmation costs $31 in total: $25 plus $5 in fees plus a $1 technology fee. The guide to whether you can cancel or reschedule a car service covers changes in more detail.
Ready to Book Your JetBlack Car Service?
When cheapest is not the cheapest trip
The train is the cheapest rung and the wrong choice on four kinds of trip. Late at night, the train runs thin, the connection at Jamaica waits longer, and the local ride from Amityville station may not be waiting. With heavy luggage, the AirTrain, the platform change at Jamaica, and the walk from the station multiply every bag into a burden. With a party of four or more, the per-person train total plus the last-mile ride meets or beats the car quote, and the car delivers the whole party to the door. In bad weather, the uncovered parts of the train journey, the platform and the station walk, cost comfort and time that no fare saving repays. On any of these trips, the cheapest car quote is the cheapest trip, because the total includes the door, the luggage, and the clock, not just the seat.
No verified JetBlack flight-delay pickup policy exists. If your flight time changes, confirm the pickup with dispatch before you travel and do not assume the pickup changes on its own. Get any revised pickup time in writing. That rule matters most on a cheapest-trip plan, because a changed flight can push a train journey into the late-night pattern, where the connections thin out and the last-mile ride disappears, and the traveler who confirmed the car booking has a fallback that the traveler who relied on the train alone does not.
The taxi rule, as context
The taxi rule is context for this comparison, not the answer. A New York City taxi ride from JFK to Amityville is a negotiated flat fare agreed before the trip under Rate #05, the driver may decline the trip, and the $0.50 MTA State Surcharge is added on top because the $0.50 applies only to trips starting in New York City and ending in New York City, Dutchess, Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, Suffolk, or Westchester, and this trip starts at JFK in New York City and ends in Amityville in Suffolk County, so the start test passes. The $1.00 improvement surcharge applies as well, and no meter runs on a Rate #05 trip. The $70 JFK to Manhattan flat fare does not apply, because it covers Manhattan only, and the $65 JFK to Manhattan economy flat for car service does not price this ride either. The taxi from JFK to Amityville flat rate page covers the taxi side. A negotiated taxi fare can beat a car quote or lose to it, and the only way to know is to get both numbers in writing before choosing.
Questions travelers ask
What is the cheapest car service from JFK to Amityville?
The cheapest car is an economy sedan on a written per-trip quote confirmed before travel: no published flat fare covers the JFK to Amityville run, and the JFK to Manhattan economy flat of $65 covers Manhattan only. The cheapest overall option is the train at $18.50 off-peak or $22.00 at peak per person, and a party of four should compare the $74 to $88 train total against one car quote split four ways.
How much is the train from JFK to Amityville?
The train costs $18.50 off-peak or $22.00 at peak per person: the $8.75 AirTrain to Jamaica plus a Long Island Rail Road train from Jamaica to Amityville at $9.75 off-peak or $13.25 at peak. The Long Island Rail Road ride from Jamaica to Amityville takes about 37 minutes. The train stops at Amityville station, not at the door, so add a local ride for the last mile.
How far is Amityville from JFK Airport?
The drive from JFK to Amityville measures 22.1 miles and 33 minutes with no traffic. Amityville is a village in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, on the South Shore of Long Island, with a population of 9,500 in the 2020 census. Plan 45 minutes to an hour with traffic.
Is a taxi from JFK to Amityville a flat fare?
A New York City taxi ride from JFK to Amityville is a negotiated flat fare agreed before the trip under Rate #05, the driver may decline the trip, and the $0.50 MTA State Surcharge is added on top because the $0.50 applies only to trips starting in New York City and ending in New York City, Dutchess, Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, Suffolk, or Westchester, and this trip starts at JFK in New York City and ends in Amityville in Suffolk County. The $70 JFK to Manhattan flat fare does not apply.
When is the cheapest option not the cheapest trip?
Late at night, with heavy luggage, with a party of four or more, or in bad weather, the train plus the last-mile ride can cost as much as a car quote while delivering less: the train stops at the station, not the door, and the connections thin out late. On those trips, the cheapest car quote is the cheapest trip, because the total includes the door, the luggage, and the clock.
Sources
- Wikipedia, Amityville, New York, checked November 15, 2026: village in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, on the South Shore of Long Island, population 9,500 in the 2020 census, incorporated March 3, 1894, a small portion in the Town of Oyster Bay
- OSRM demo server route queries, November 15, 2026: JFK to Amityville 22.1 miles and 33 minutes, Jamaica to Amityville 23.9 miles and 35 minutes
- MTA, How to get to Manhattan from JFK Airport: AirTrain fare $8.75, accessed November 15, 2026
- MTA fare chart effective January 4, 2026, and MTA zone table, checked November 15, 2026: Long Island Rail Road Zone 3 at Jamaica to Zone 9 at Amityville one-way $9.75 off-peak and $13.25 peak, peak defined as weekday trains arriving at a New York terminal 6:00 AM to 10:00 AM or leaving 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM
- Commuterlines.com, MTA open data and GTFS, checked November 15, 2026: Babylon to Jamaica $13.25, 48 minutes, 7 stops, Babylon to Amityville $3.75, 11 minutes, 2 stops, from which the Jamaica to Amityville ride of about 37 minutes is derived
- New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission, taxi fare page, nyc.gov: Rate #05 negotiated flat fare for other points outside the city, driver may decline, $0.50 MTA State Surcharge added on top of Rate #05 flats for trips starting in New York City and ending in Dutchess, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, or Suffolk, $1.00 improvement surcharge, JFK to Manhattan $70 flat fare plus surcharges, accessed November 15, 2026
- Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Approved Fee Changes, Aviation: for-hire vehicle access fee $3.50 pickup and drop-off effective March 15, 2026, accessed November 15, 2026
- JetBlack Transportation, owner-confirmed service facts (JFK to Manhattan economy flat $65, Manhattan only and not covering Amityville, hourly rate sheet: Economy Sedan $45 per hour with a 3-hour minimum, Luxury Sedan $55 per hour with a 3-hour minimum, Economy SUV $72 per hour with a 3-hour minimum, Luxury SUV $80 per hour with a 3-hour minimum, Premium Sedan $100 per hour with a 3-hour minimum, Economy Van $120 per hour with a 4-hour minimum, Sprinter $130 per hour with a 4-hour minimum and a $520 floor, stretch limousine $144 per hour with a 4-hour minimum and a $576 floor seating 6 to 25, gratuity not included with a 20% tip suggested, cancellation free before confirmation and $31 total after confirmation: $25 plus $5 in fees plus a $1 technology fee, child seats about $35 per seat for a fee, wheelchair-accessible vehicles provided, dispatch 24/7, since 2010, no verified flight-delay pickup policy, $44 first-mile per-mile tier), confirmed October 26, 2026, accessed November 15, 2026
JetBlack Transportation · 34 W 34th St, New York, NY 10001 · +1-646-214-4828 · Fares and schedules verified November 2026 and subject to change — confirm your quote and pickup time in writing before travel





