Cheapest first: the transit chain to Richmond Valley on Staten Island, not a car. AirTrain JFK to Jamaica, subway into Manhattan, the Staten Island Ferry, and a local bus into Richmond Valley costs roughly $14.65 in fares in total and takes roughly 2 hours or more, while a car is far faster and far more expensive, so the honest answer starts with the chain and prices the car second.

The drive, priced honestly
JFK to Richmond Valley is about 30 miles via the Belt Parkway and the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, roughly 50 minutes clear and 1 hour 20 minutes to 1 hour 40 minutes in traffic. The taxi meter on the same 30-mile run works out at $108.00 on the meter formula of $3.00 plus $0.70 per fifth of a mile, before tolls, surcharges, and tip, and slow-traffic time can add more. A booked car is quoted per trip in writing before travel, not on that meter.
Neither the $70 taxi flat fare nor the $65 booked-car economy fare applies here, since both are Manhattan trips and Richmond Valley is on Staten Island. Any page that quotes either figure for this trip is borrowing a Manhattan fare.
When the car is worth it
For one person travelling light with plenty of time, the transit chain wins on price by a wide margin. For a group, for heavy bags, for a late arrival, or for a flight that lands when the ferry and bus connections are thin, the booked car’s door-to-door total, fixed in writing, is the fair comparison, and it should be compared as a total, not per person against a single transit fare.