Booking a taxi from LaGuardia to JFK is a curbside job, not an app job — and the honest price is the meter, shown worked out below, not a borrowed flat fare.

How to book it
At LaGuardia, go to the taxi stand for your terminal — Terminal B and Terminal C each have signed, staffed stands — and join the queue; dispatchers assign the next cab in line. There is no pre-booking a yellow cab to JFK in the usual sense: the stand is the booking. If you want a guaranteed car at a guaranteed time, that is a booked car, not a taxi: give JetBlack the flight number, the LaGuardia terminal, and the JFK terminal at booking, and dispatch tracks the flight so a delay moves the pickup.
The meter math for the roughly 12-mile run: the meter starts at $3.00 and adds $0.70 for every fifth of a mile. Over 12 miles that is 60 fifths, or $42.00, plus the $3.00 start — $45.00 before tolls, tip, and surcharges. Allow 30 to 50 minutes in normal traffic, more at peak. Two fares do not apply here and are worth naming: the $70 flat fare covers JFK and Manhattan only, and JetBlack’s $65 JFK–Manhattan economy fare is a different trip entirely.
The cheaper alternative, and the timing rule
The transit chain — bus or subway from LaGuardia to Jamaica, then AirTrain JFK at $8.75 — costs far less than the taxi but takes roughly 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours door to door with changes. Whichever option you choose, the timing rule for a connection is the same: allow at least an hour between landing at LaGuardia and the onward departure from JFK, and two hours if you can afford it, because the inter-airport transfer is the part of the journey most likely to go wrong.
Book Your New York Ride With the Price in Writing
How do I book a taxi from LGA to JFK?
Use the signed, staffed taxi stand at your LaGuardia terminal — the stand is the booking; yellow cabs are not pre-booked.
What does the taxi cost?
About $45.00 on the meter before tolls, tip, and surcharges, for a roughly 12-mile run.
What is the cheapest way?
The bus and subway chain to Jamaica plus AirTrain JFK at $8.75 — far cheaper, roughly 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours.