From New Haven, Connecticut to JFK Airport, the ranked options are a booked car, the rail chain, and a bus combination, and the honest ranking depends on whether you value time, price, or door-to-door simplicity. A booked car is fastest and simplest at roughly 75 miles door to door, the rail chain is cheapest for one person travelling light, and neither the $65 JFK-Manhattan booked-car fare nor any Manhattan flat fare applies here, since New Haven is in Connecticut.

The options, ranked
By booked car: about 75 miles from New Haven to JFK, roughly 1 hour 45 minutes clear and 2 hours 30 minutes or more in traffic, door to door, with the total fixed in writing before travel and flight tracking on the pickup. By rail: Metro-North New Haven Line from New Haven to Grand Central, then subway or Long Island Rail Road to Jamaica, then AirTrain JFK to the terminals, roughly 3 hours to 3 hours 30 minutes in total including connections, and the cheapest option for one person travelling light.
By bus combination: intercity bus into Manhattan plus the subway and AirTrain chain to JFK, usually longer than the rail chain and only worth it when its timetable fits your flight better. A taxi from New Haven to JFK is metered over the same long distance and should never be quoted as a flat Manhattan fare.
Ready to Book Your New Haven to JFK Ride?
Which one to choose
Choose the booked car for a group, for heavy bags, for a tight connection, or for a late arrival, and accept that traffic on the Connecticut and New York crossings decides the time. Choose the rail chain when price matters most and you have a generous connection, and build in a buffer at Grand Central and at Jamaica, because a missed connection is what turns a 3-hour chain into a missed flight.