A taxi from JFK Airport to Blooming Grove, New York, in Orange County, works out at about $248.00 on the meter formula of $3.00 plus $0.70 per fifth of a mile for the roughly 70-mile run, before tolls, surcharges, and tip, and slow-traffic time can add more. That figure is shown so you can check a quote, not as the fare you will pay: for a run this long, a booked car is quoted per trip in writing before travel, and that written total, not the meter, is the figure that governs.

The run, priced honestly
JFK to Blooming Grove is roughly 70 miles, via the Van Wyck Expressway, the Robert F. Kennedy Bridge, and the New York State Thruway north into Orange County, roughly 1 hour 30 minutes clear and 2 hours or more in traffic. The meter figure above is the arithmetic on that distance, and it is the reason a taxi is the wrong tool for this trip: no driver will hold a metered fare steady over 70 miles of Thruway traffic, and the final total will be decided by traffic, not by distance.
A booked car for the same run is quoted per trip in writing before travel, with flight tracking on the pickup and the total fixed before you leave the terminal. Book online at jetblacktransportation.com/p/reservation/ or call +1-646-214-4828, and give the exact Blooming Grove address, because Orange County covers a wide area and the address decides the route.
The cheaper alternative, kept honest
The cheaper way is transit plus a local taxi: AirTrain JFK to Jamaica, the subway or Long Island Rail Road into Manhattan, then a train north and a local taxi for the last leg, roughly 3 hours or more in total. It is far cheaper for one person travelling light with plenty of time, and the wrong choice for a group, for heavy bags, or for a tight connection, because each transfer is a place the journey can break.