By limo or booked car, LaGuardia Airport to Port Jervis in Orange County, New York, takes about 1 hour 50 minutes in clear traffic and 2 hours to 2 hours 30 minutes as a realistic planning figure — this is a long upstate run, not an airport-to-city hop, and it should be quoted as one.

The route and the distance
The drive is about 76 miles. The usual routing runs from LaGuardia across the Whitestone Bridge, then north on the Hutchinson River Parkway and I-287, up I-87, and west toward Port Jervis. Traffic on the city crossings and on I-87 is what stretches the trip; the mileage does not change, and a quote that ignores rush hour will not survive contact with it.
A limo for this run is booked per trip, not on a taxi meter, and JetBlack quotes it per trip in writing before travel. Ask for the total to be named — base fare, tolls, and any waiting or airport fee — and for the pickup plan to be confirmed against your flight, because a delayed arrival on a 2-hour run matters more than on a 20-minute one. The $65 JFK–Manhattan economy fare has nothing to do with this trip, and neither does any Manhattan flat fare; both belong to Manhattan trips only.
Is there a cheaper way?
The budget alternative is a transit chain, and it is long: subway or bus from LaGuardia into Manhattan, then a train north and a local connection toward Port Jervis, with total times that can exceed 3 hours and a last leg that still needs a taxi or a lift. For one person with light bags and plenty of time, that chain works. For a group, for heavy bags, or for a late arrival, the booked car is the honest recommendation, and the per-trip quote is the price to compare.