Choose the airport your airline actually serves nonstop, then check the ground trip to your final address — that order settles Newark vs JFK for most travelers, because neither airport wins on every measure. JFK lists 72 airlines across five terminals, while Newark lists 37 across three, so JFK usually offers the wider choice of carriers and routings; Newark counters with a United-centered operation and a rail leg to New York Penn Station of about 30 minutes. On the ground, the cheapest rail trip from JFK to Manhattan is $11.75, the NJ Transit rail trip from Newark to Penn Station is $17.25, a taxi from JFK to Manhattan is a $70 flat fare before surcharges, and a taxi to Newark runs on the meter plus a $20.00 Newark surcharge and tolls in both directions — so the right airport depends on your ticket and your destination, not on a single ranking.
Picture a traveler comparing two fares to a hotel near Penn Station: a United nonstop into Newark Terminal C, and a JetBlue flight into JFK Terminal 5 with a connection. The Newark ticket lands closer to the hotel by rail, by AirTrain to the airport station and then a train to Penn Station, while the JFK ticket means AirTrain to Jamaica and then the subway or LIRR into Manhattan. If the same traveler were headed to an address in Queens, the JFK ticket would win on ground time instead, because JFK sits in Queens and Newark sits across the Hudson in New Jersey. This page works through the airline, terminal, train, taxi, and driving facts behind that choice, with every fare checked on November 13, 2026.
Written by David Williams · Fact-checked by Alex Freeman, Editor-in-Chief · Last verified November 2026

Start with your airline, not the airport
The official airline lists, both checked November 13, 2026, set the scale of the choice. JFK lists 72 airlines, and Newark lists 37. More airlines does not mean a better flight for you — it means more chances that your carrier, your alliance, and your nonstop already exist at JFK. At Newark, United operates across Terminals A, B, and C, and Terminal C is operated by United, so a United or Star Alliance itinerary usually lives at Newark. At JFK, the anchors are Delta at Terminal 4, JetBlue at Terminal 5, and American at Terminal 8. Check the terminal printed on your boarding pass before you leave for the airport, because assignments change during the JFK rebuild and some arrivals use a different terminal than departures: JetBlue international arrivals overnight use Terminal 4, for example, while JetBlue departures use Terminal 5.
- Five terminals in use at JFK: 1, 4, 5, 7, and 8
- Three terminals in use at Newark: A, B, and C
- Delta at JFK Terminal 4, JetBlue at JFK Terminal 5, and American at JFK Terminal 8
- United at Newark Terminals A and C, with some overnight international arrivals at Terminal B
- International carriers spread across JFK Terminals 1 and 4 and Newark Terminal B
The terminal also decides your pickup. Tell your driver the terminal on your boarding pass, not the terminal you flew from last year, and confirm how many terminals JFK has before you assume the numbering. At JFK Terminal 7, pick-up and drop-off moved inside the Terminal 7 parking garage on September 22, 2026, until further notice, with the taxi stand on Level 1, so a Terminal 7 pickup does not happen at the old curb. For Delta, the Terminal 4 anchor, confirm which terminal Delta uses at JFK on your travel date rather than trusting a saved address.
Ready to Book Your JetBlack Car Service?
Getting to Manhattan: trains, buses, and what each leg really costs
From JFK, every rail trip starts with the AirTrain, which links the terminals to Jamaica Station and Howard Beach Station. The one-way AirTrain fare between JFK and those stations is $8.75, charged when you enter or exit at Jamaica or Howard Beach, and rides between terminals are free. From Jamaica, the E, J, or Z subway lines run into Manhattan, and the LIRR runs to Penn Station, Grand Central, or Atlantic Terminal; from Howard Beach, the A train runs into Manhattan. The subway route totals $11.75 for most riders, a $3.00 subway fare plus the $8.75 AirTrain fare, and the LIRR route totals $14.00 off-peak or $16.00 at peak, a $5.25 or $7.25 CityTicket plus the $8.75 AirTrain fare. AirTrain trains between terminals run every 5 to 15 minutes. Before you plan around the fare, confirm what the JFK AirTrain costs and that AirTrain rides between JFK terminals are free, so a terminal change never costs a second fare.
From Newark, the AirTrain runs from the terminals to Newark Liberty International Airport Station, where NJ Transit and Amtrak trains stop. The one-way AirTrain fare to or from that station is $8.75 per person on its own, and it is included in an NJ Transit or Amtrak ticket to or from the airport. NJ Transit to Midtown Manhattan takes about 30 minutes on the train and costs $17.25, and the Port Authority table also lists NJ Transit plus PATH combinations at $11.75: 40 minutes to the 33rd Street PATH station and 45 minutes to the World Trade Center. The Newark Airport Express Bus stops at every terminal and serves Grand Central Terminal, Bryant Park, and the Port Authority Bus Terminal in about 50 minutes for $23.50 one way. Allow 15 to 20 minutes to get from the airport train station to your terminal, on top of the train leg, because the station sits outside the terminal loop. No Newark terminal has its own train station, so every rail trip passes through the same AirTrain link — see which Newark terminals connect to New York City trains, the EWR AirTrain and its rail-station link, and the public transportation options from Manhattan to Newark Airport.
As checked November 13, 2026, the official Newark advisory states that AirTrain Newark was not serving the Newark Airport Train Station Monday through Friday, from 5:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., during construction of the new AirTrain, with free shuttle buses covering the link and an extra 10 to 15 minutes advised. The posted window in the page metadata, July 27 through November 13, 2026, for Terminals A, B, and C, ended November 13, 2026. Service between the terminals themselves was not affected, and the AirTrain operated normally on weekends and outside those hours. Do not carry the posted window forward: check the live Port Authority advisory for your exact travel date and hour before you rely on the rail link, because construction schedules change.
Overnight, the two airports diverge. NJ Transit train service is not a 24-hour service: trains run between about 5 a.m. and 1 a.m., and for overnight travel the public-transit path is the PATH train plus the NJ Transit 62 bus, with the PATH Newark to World Trade Center line running around the clock, less frequently overnight. At JFK, the MTA guide warns that overnight service runs local on some lines and to allow extra time. For a late-night Newark arrival, confirm the overnight path before you land or book door-to-door transport, rather than assuming a train will be waiting at the airport station.
Taxis and cars: a flat fare on one side, a meter on the other
A yellow taxi between JFK and Manhattan charges a $70 flat fare in either direction, and the meter should read Rate #2. The full stack before tolls and tip, for a trip touching Manhattan south of 96th Street, is $76.75: the $70 flat fare plus the $0.50 MTA State Surcharge, the $1.00 improvement surcharge, the $2.00 airport access fee on pickups, the $2.50 New York State Congestion Surcharge for Manhattan south of 96th Street, and the 75-cent MTA Congestion Pricing toll for Manhattan south of and including 60th Street. On weekdays from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m., excluding legal holidays, a $5.00 rush-hour surcharge raises the pre-toll, pre-tip total to $81.75. Note the two zone scopes: the $2.50 surcharge zone and the 75-cent toll zone are different, and the $2.00 access fee applies to pickups only, so a Manhattan-to-JFK drop-off total runs $2.00 lower before tolls and tip. For the full treatment, see how much a taxi from JFK to Manhattan costs.
A yellow taxi to Newark Airport has no flat fare. The TLC rule is the standard metered fare plus a $20.00 Newark surcharge, plus tip and tolls to and from EWR, with the passenger charged for the driver’s return tolls, and the meter should read Rate #3. The meter starts at $3.00 and adds 70 cents per fifth of a mile above 12 mph or per 60 seconds in slow traffic or when stopped, so traffic time moves the fare and no fixed total exists for the trip. There is no doubling on a Newark trip — doubling belongs to the Nassau and Westchester rule only — and the $0.50 MTA State Surcharge does not apply, because the tax applies only to trips that start in New York City and end in New York City or one of seven named New York counties, and New Jersey is on neither list. The standard metered-fare surcharges apply where the trip meets their conditions, including the congestion charges when the Manhattan end sits in their zones. Compare the best way to travel from Manhattan to EWR Airport before assuming the taxi meter will beat a written car-service quote.
JetBlack pricing follows the same split. An Economy Sedan from JFK to Manhattan is a $65 flat fare, agreed in writing before the car moves. For Newark to Manhattan, no verified JetBlack per-trip fare is published for this page, so the honest price is a written per-trip quote agreed before travel — never the JFK fare borrowed across the Hudson. Hourly service is priced separately from per-trip fares: an Economy Sedan is $45 an hour with a 3-hour minimum, a Premium Sedan is $100 an hour with a 3-hour minimum, and a Sprinter is $130 an hour with a 4-hour minimum and a $520 hourly floor. The $44 figure is the first-mile per-mile tier, not an hourly floor and not a trip price. Buses are contact for a quote, with no published rate. Child seats cost about $35 per seat, confirmed at booking, and are never free; wheelchair-accessible vehicles are provided on request. Cancellation is free before confirmation and $31 in total after confirmation: $25 plus $5 in fees plus a $1 technology fee. A 20% tip is suggested and not included, and tolls, governmental fees, and on-trip amenities sit outside the quoted fare. No verified JetBlack flight-delay pickup policy exists, so if your flight runs late, ask at booking how the pickup is handled and get the answer in writing. For the wider Newark picture, see getting from Newark Airport to Manhattan and weigh each option against the written quote.
Driving distance and the transfer trap
A route-planner check on November 13, 2026, from each airport to the 34th Street area of Midtown Manhattan, put JFK at 17.3 miles and about 30 minutes, and Newark at 16.3 miles and about 31 minutes. Those are free-flow planner estimates, not promises: peak traffic, construction, and the Hudson crossings add time that neither estimate captures, and the two drives sit within about a mile of each other, so distance alone does not pick a winner. What distance does decide is the transfer between the airports. The same planner check put JFK to Newark at 31.2 miles and about 56 minutes before traffic, and no direct rail link connects the two airports. A public-transit move between them crosses Manhattan by AirTrain, subway or LIRR, NJ Transit, and AirTrain again. If you hold separate tickets into one airport and out of the other, treat the move as a cross-city drive, confirm the plan with both airlines, and leave far more time than the drive estimate suggests. For the transfer itself, compare the fastest way to get from JFK to EWR with traveling from JFK to EWR using public transportation.
A decision list for the two fares in front of you
Use the facts above in this order: airline first, final address second, ground cost third. The list below applies that order to the choices travelers actually face.
- A United or Star Alliance nonstop: Newark, where United centers its operation at Terminal C
- A Delta, JetBlue, or American nonstop: JFK, at Terminals 4, 5, and 8 respectively
- A final address in New Jersey or near New York Penn Station: Newark, on the NJ Transit rail leg
- A final address in Queens, Brooklyn, or Long Island: JFK, without a Hudson crossing
- The cheapest solo rail trip with light bags: JFK by AirTrain and subway at $11.75, or Newark by the NJ Transit and PATH combination at $11.75 where it serves your destination
- A late-night arrival with no overnight timetable checked: confirm the overnight path before choosing Newark, or book door-to-door transport
- Heavy bags, children, or a group: a door-to-door car with a written quote, from either airport
- Two separate tickets across the two airports: rethink the booking, since the airports sit about 31 miles apart by road
Questions travelers ask
Which airport is closer to Manhattan, EWR or JFK?
By road to Midtown Manhattan, the two airports are nearly even: a route-planner check on November 13, 2026 put JFK at 17.3 miles and Newark at 16.3 miles from the 34th Street area, with free-flow drive times of about 30 and 31 minutes. Free-flow times ignore traffic, so neither figure is a promise at rush hour. Pick by your airline and your final address, not by the one-mile difference.
Which airport should I choose if I fly United, Delta, or JetBlue?
United centers its Newark operation at Terminal C and also uses Terminal A, so a United itinerary usually points to Newark. Delta uses Terminal 4 at JFK and JetBlue uses Terminal 5 at JFK, so those itineraries usually point to JFK. Always confirm the terminal on your boarding pass, because assignments change and some arrivals use a different terminal than departures.
Is the train cheaper from EWR or JFK?
From JFK, AirTrain plus subway costs $11.75, and AirTrain plus LIRR costs $14.00 off-peak or $16.00 at peak. From Newark, NJ Transit to New York Penn Station costs $17.25 with the AirTrain included, while the NJ Transit and PATH combinations to 33rd Street or the World Trade Center cost $11.75. The cheapest rail fare is a tie at $11.75, but the routes serve different Manhattan stations, so check which station sits closest to your destination.
Can I fly into one airport and out of the other?
You can, but treat it as a cross-city drive, not a connection: the two airports sit about 31 miles apart by road, a route-planner estimate of about 56 minutes before traffic, and no direct rail link connects them. A public-transit chain crosses Manhattan and takes far longer. Confirm the plan with both airlines, keep your bags with you between airports, and leave far more time than the drive estimate suggests.
Is the EWR AirTrain running normally?
As checked November 13, 2026, the official Newark advisory posted a partial outage from July 27 through November 13, 2026, with shuttle buses replacing the AirTrain link to the airport train station on weekdays from 5:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. and service between terminals unaffected. That posted window ended November 13, 2026, so do not carry it forward: check the live Port Authority advisory for your travel date before you rely on the rail link.
Sources
- JFK Airport — All Airlines: 72 airlines, terminals 1, 4, 5, 7, and 8, Delta Terminal 4, JetBlue Terminal 5 with overnight international arrivals at Terminal 4, American Terminal 8, accessed 2026-11-13
- Newark Airport — All Airlines: 37 airlines, Terminals A, B, and C, United across Terminals A, B, and C, accessed 2026-11-13
- Newark Airport — Explore All Terminals: three terminals, Terminal A opened 2023, Terminal C operated by United, accessed 2026-11-13
- JFK Airport — AirTrain JFK: $8.75 one-way fare to Jamaica or Howard Beach, free between terminals, trains every 5 to 15 minutes, accessed 2026-11-13
- Newark Airport — Public Transportation: $8.75 AirTrain fare, NJ Transit to Midtown about 30 minutes at $17.25, NJ Transit plus PATH combinations at $11.75, Express Bus $23.50 one way in about 50 minutes, accessed 2026-11-13
- Newark Airport — AirTrain Newark Partial Service Outage: raw HTML and page metadata checked 2026-11-13, Dates July 27 through November 13, 2026, Locations Terminals A, B, and C, weekday 5:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. shuttle buses, 10 to 15 extra minutes advised
- NYC Taxi and Limousine Commission — Taxi Fare: $3.00 meter start, 70 cents per fifth of a mile or 60 seconds, $70 JFK to Manhattan flat fare with surcharge stack, $20.00 Newark surcharge, $2.00 airport access fee pickup only, congestion zones, accessed 2026-11-13
- MTA — How to get to JFK Airport on public transit: $11.75 subway plus AirTrain total, $14.00 and $16.00 LIRR plus AirTrain totals, $5.25 off-peak and $7.25 peak Jamaica tickets, overnight local service warning, accessed 2026-11-13
- MTA — How to get to Newark Airport on public transit: NJ Transit trains run about 5 a.m. to 1 a.m. and are not a 24-hour service, PATH plus 62 bus overnight path, 15 to 20 minutes station to terminal, accessed 2026-11-13 — fare figures on this guide are stale and were not used; all Newark fares above come from the Port Authority page
- OSRM route planner: JFK to Midtown 17.3 miles and about 30 minutes, Newark to Midtown 16.3 miles and about 31 minutes, JFK to Newark 31.2 miles and about 56 minutes, free-flow estimates checked 2026-11-13
- JetBlack Transportation — owner-confirmed service facts and owner price list (JFK to Manhattan economy $65 flat, Economy Sedan $45 an hour with 3-hour minimum, Premium Sedan $100 an hour with 3-hour minimum, Sprinter $130 an hour with 4-hour minimum and $520 floor, $44 first-mile per-mile tier, child seats about $35 per seat for a fee, wheelchair-accessible vehicles provided, cancellation $31 breakdown, 20% suggested tip excluded), price list 2026-10-03, accessed 2026-11-13
JetBlack Transportation · 34 W 34th St, New York, NY 10001 · +1-646-214-4828 · Prices verified November 2026 and subject to change — confirm your fixed quote in writing before you travel

