There are no additional per-bag luggage charges when taking a taxi from JFK Airport to Manhattan, stated plainly: New York City yellow taxis do not charge per bag, and the JFK to Manhattan flat fare already covers the ride. What you pay is the flat fare plus its published adds, plus tolls and tip, and any per-bag charge quoted for a yellow taxi on this run is not a published taxi charge.

The flat fare and its adds, summing exactly
The JFK to Manhattan taxi flat fare is $70, and the published adds bring it to $76.75 base and $81.75 in weekday rush hours. The stack sums exactly: $70 plus $0.50 MTA surcharge, plus $1.00 improvement surcharge, plus $2.00 JFK airport access fee, plus $2.50 state congestion surcharge, plus $0.75 congestion-pricing toll, equals $76.75, and the $5.00 rush surcharge on weekdays from 4pm to 8pm brings it to $81.75. Tolls on the route, where the driver uses a tolled crossing, are added on top, and gratuity is separate, with 20% suggested for a good ride.
No line in that stack is a luggage charge, and no luggage charge is added after it. A driver who quotes a per-bag fee on top of the flat fare for a yellow taxi is not quoting the published tariff, and the fare should be challenged at the time, with the medallion number and the receipt kept as the record.
Booked cars are different, and that is fine
A booked car is not a taxi, so its pricing works differently: the JFK to Manhattan booked-car economy fare is $65, quoted per trip in writing before travel, with tolls, governmental fees, and amenities inside the written total, and gratuity not included, with 20% suggested. Luggage does not change the booked-car total either, provided the vehicle class booked actually fits the bags, which is why the headcount and bag count belong in the booking itself.
For a group or heavy bags, book the class that fits, confirm the written total, and the luggage question is settled before the car arrives. Book online at jetblacktransportation.com/p/reservation/ or call +1-646-214-4828.

