Booking a taxi from JFK to Manhattan is simplest at the terminal taxi stands: follow the signs to the taxi queue at your terminal, give the dispatcher your Manhattan address, and take the next cab in line. The fare is a flat fare, not a metered fare: $70 plus surcharges, which comes to $76.75 before tip in normal hours and $81.75 in rush hours, and the driver must accept a card — cash is not required and a card refusal is a complaint, not a negotiation.
You do not need to book a yellow taxi in advance, and you should not pay anyone who approaches you inside the terminal offering a ride — those are unlicensed solicitors, and the legitimate queue is outside at the marked stand. If you want a car waiting for you with a named driver and a written total, that is a booked car, not a taxi, and the price is different: JetBlack’s JFK to Manhattan economy fare is $65, quoted in writing before travel.

At the stand, step by step
At your terminal, follow the taxi signs to the outdoor queue and join the line — dispatchers manage the queue at busy times and will direct you to the next cab. Give the driver the exact Manhattan address, not just a neighbourhood, and confirm the flat fare before you leave the airport: $70 flat, plus the $0.50 MTA surcharge, the $1.00 improvement surcharge, and the $5.00 rush-hour surcharge from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m. on weekdays, which is how the total reaches $76.75, or $81.75 in rush hours. Tolls on the route are extra and are shown on the meter as they occur.
During the ride, the meter should show the flat fare, not a running distance total, and the receipt at the end should itemise the fare, surcharges, tolls, and tip separately. Tip is not included — 20% is the suggested figure. If the driver refuses a card, demands cash, or quotes a price above the flat fare, note the medallion number and report it to the Taxi and Limousine Commission; do not argue at the curb.
Taxi or booked car
The taxi wins on immediacy: no booking, no wait for a named driver, a regulated flat fare. The booked car wins on certainty: a driver waiting with your name, a total fixed in writing before travel, and flight tracking so a delay moves the pickup. For a solo traveller with light bags, the taxi queue is the honest default; for a group, a late arrival, or a tight schedule, compare the $76.75 taxi total against the $65 booked-car fare and choose on certainty, not just on price.