The short answer: take AirTrain Newark to the rail station, then NJ Transit to New York Penn Station. One adult ticket of about $17.25 covers the AirTrain and the train, and the whole trip runs about 35 to 50 minutes door to door. It is the fastest cheap way in for a solo traveler or a couple with light bags; a taxi or a booked car wins when the bags are heavy, the group is large, or the train has stopped for the night.

Book Your New York Ride With the Price in Writing
The train, step by step
AirTrain Newark runs free between Terminals A, B, and C and out to Newark Liberty International Airport Station. There you board a Northeast Corridor or North Jersey Coast Line train toward New York Penn Station — about 30 minutes on the train itself. Buy the ticket in the NJ Transit app before you ride, and check the departure board first: not every train stops at the airport station, and tickets bought on board cost more. On weekday mornings and afternoons, shuttle buses sometimes replace the AirTrain link to the rail station during construction, so check the NJ Transit advisory before you travel. Trains run roughly 5 a.m. to 1 a.m.; outside those hours you need a car.
The other ways in
A taxi from EWR is metered, plus a $20.00 Newark surcharge on top of the meter, and the ride to Midtown runs 45 minutes to 90 minutes or more depending on traffic. Rideshare pickups sit in a lot away from the terminals, so follow the app directions rather than the taxi line. The budget chain is local bus 62 to Newark Penn Station, then PATH into Manhattan, then the subway — cheaper than the through ticket, slower, and a worse idea with heavy bags. A booked car is a per-trip written quote with a driver tracking your flight; JetBlack quotes EWR trips per trip in writing, with flight tracking, express curbside pickup as the default, and meet and greet as a paid extra.
Which one to pick
Traveling light and landing before midnight, take the train: it is the cheapest and usually the fastest. Traveling with children, several checked bags, or a tight connection, take a taxi or a booked car and skip the transfers. Landing after the last train, the car is the only sensible choice — book it before you fly, because the curb at 2 a.m. is no place to start comparing prices.
Where JetBlack fits
JetBlack, 34 W 34th St, New York, NY 10001, has run car service in New York since 2010: mileage-based fares from a $44 starting price, the $65 fixed route fare between JFK and Manhattan, flight tracking on airport pickups, express curbside pickup as the default, and meet and greet as a paid extra. Dispatch answers 24/7 on +1-646-214-4828. If this page answered your question, the booking takes a minute; if it did not, call and a person will.
Related questions: JFK airport car service: the quick guide · The cheapest way to get from JFK to Greenport · Authoritative sources: NYC Taxi and Limousine Commission · Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.
How do i Get from Newark Airport to the City?
Take AirTrain Newark to Newark Liberty International Airport Station, then NJ Transit to New York Penn Station. One adult ticket of about $17.25 covers the AirTrain and the train, and the trip runs about 35 to 50 minutes door to door. Buy the ticket in the NJ Transit app before you ride and check the departure board, since not every train stops at the airport station.
What should I look for in a New York car service?
A fixed quote in writing, licensed and insured vehicles, flight tracking on airport trips, and a dispatch number a person answers. JetBlack has run on those four since 2010.
How is a car service different from a taxi or an app?
A taxi is hailed and metered, plus the $20.00 Newark surcharge at EWR; an app reprices with demand. A car service is booked ahead at a confirmed price with a planned pickup — the difference shows up exactly when a trip has a deadline.
How do I book?
Book online or call +1-646-214-4828. Cancellation is free before confirmation; after confirmation the fee totals $31 ($25 + $5 + $1).