There is no single scheduled shuttle with one published fare between LaGuardia and JFK — no bus with a fixed timetable and a fixed price that runs airport to airport. What exists is a choice: a shared-ride van or car booked in advance, a taxi, a booked car, or a public-transit chain. Anyone quoting a single “LaGuardia to JFK shuttle price” without naming an operator is quoting a guess, because shared-ride fares are set per operator and per booking, not published as one fare.
The prices that are published are the taxi meter and the transit fares, and those give the honest comparison. A taxi covers the roughly 12-mile run on the meter; the transit chain costs a few dollars in bus, subway, and AirTrain fares; a booked car is quoted per trip in writing. Allow at least an hour for the transfer and two hours to be comfortable, whatever mode you choose.

The published prices: taxi and transit
By taxi, the roughly 12-mile run meters at $45.00 before tolls, tip, and surcharges — the meter starts at $3.00 and adds $0.70 per fifth of a mile, so 12 miles is 60 fifths at $0.70, or $42.00, plus the $3.00 start. The $70 flat fare and the $65 booked-car fare do not apply here: the flat fare covers JFK and Manhattan only, and the $65 fare is a JFK to Manhattan booked-car fare, not a LaGuardia to JFK fare. By transit, the chain is the Q70 bus plus subway plus AirTrain JFK — $2.90 plus $3 plus $8.75, or $14.65 in total — taking roughly 1 hour to 1 hour 30 minutes.
Shared-ride operators quote per person for a pre-booked LaGuardia to JFK ride, and the fare depends on the operator, the time of day, and how many passengers share the vehicle — check the operator\u2019s own quote for your date rather than relying on a single figure. A private booked car is quoted per trip in writing before you travel; give both terminals and both flight numbers at booking so dispatch can track the flights.
Choosing by connection time
With under an hour between flights, none of these options is safe — the transfer itself takes 30 to 50 minutes by road in good traffic and longer at rush hour, and terminal changes at either airport add time. With one to two hours, a taxi or booked car is the realistic choice; with two hours or more, the transit chain is the cheapest honest option. If your connection is under an hour, contact the airline about rebooking rather than gambling on the transfer: a missed connection costs more than any transfer fare.

