From JFK to LaGuardia, the ranked options are a booked car, a metered taxi, and the transit chain, and the ranking depends on whether you value speed, price, or door-to-door simplicity. This is an airport-to-airport run of about 12 miles, and the $65 JFK-Manhattan booked-car fare is explicitly not borrowed here, because neither end of this trip is Manhattan.

The options, ranked
By booked car: door to door, terminal to terminal, roughly 30 minutes clear and 45 minutes to 1 hour in traffic, with the total fixed in writing before travel and flight tracking on the pickup, the best choice with luggage or on a tight connection. By taxi: metered between the airports, and the meter formula on the same 12-mile run works out at $45.00 before tolls, surcharges, and tip, shown as a check on a quote, not as a fixed fare, with traffic, not distance, deciding the final total.
By transit: AirTrain JFK to Jamaica, subway toward Queens, then the Q70 bus to LaGuardia, roughly 1 hour 30 minutes to 2 hours in total including connections, and the cheapest option for one person travelling light with plenty of time between flights.
Which one to choose
Choose the booked car or the taxi when the connection is tight, because the transit chain has two connections and a missed one is what turns a 1 hour 30 minute chain into a missed flight. Choose transit when price matters most and the connection is generous, and build in a buffer at Jamaica and at the bus stop, because the chain is only cheap when it is not rushed.

