LaGuardia is the most convenient airport for a hotel near Times Square on distance and price, JFK offers a direct rail path to Midtown, and Newark’s train is strong but costs the most — while a booked car is the simplest option from any of the three when luggage or a late arrival is in play. LaGuardia sits 9.2 miles from Times Square with a free bus plus a $3.00 subway ride; JFK sits 18.1 miles away with a rail path to Penn Station; Newark sits 16.2 miles away with a through train ticket to Penn Station. This page compares all three legs for convenience — distance, cheapest path, simplest path, and the hotel last block — so the choice is made on the whole trip, not on one fare.
Picture a traveler choosing between three arriving flights, all priced within a few dollars of each other, with a hotel room booked near Times Square and two suitcases. The airport choice is really a ground-trip choice: the shortest drive, the fewest changes, the least luggage handling, and the surest arrival at the hotel door. The guides to travelling from JFK to Times Square and getting from JFK to Times Square cover the JFK leg alone, and the guide to transferring from Times Square to JFK Airport covers the reverse trip. This page does the comparison those pages do not: all three airports, ranked for a Times Square hotel.
Written by Sarah Thompson · Fact-checked by Alex Freeman, Editor-in-Chief · Last verified November 2026

The three legs compared
| Airport | Drive, no traffic | Cheapest path | Simplest path |
|---|---|---|---|
| LaGuardia | 9.2 miles, 19 minutes | Free bus plus subway, $3.00 | Booked car to the hotel door |
| JFK | 18.1 miles, 32 minutes | AirTrain plus subway, $11.75 | Booked car or taxi flat fare |
| Newark | 16.2 miles, 31 minutes | Train to Penn Station, $17.25 | Booked car to the hotel door |
The table reads as a convenience ranking, not a price ranking. LaGuardia wins the distance column by a wide margin and the price column outright. JFK’s rail path reaches Penn Station without a bus, which the LaGuardia path cannot. Newark’s train ticket costs the most of the three transit paths and adds the AirTrain ride plus the platform change at the airport station, which is why it ranks third on convenience despite a shorter drive than JFK. The booked car ranks first on simplicity from every airport and last on price from every airport — that trade is the whole decision, and the sections below price each leg so it can be weighed honestly.
From JFK: a direct rail path, the longest drive
The JFK to Times Square leg is 18.1 miles and 32 minutes of no-traffic driving, the longest of the three drives, and the routed time carries no traffic, so the planning time must be longer than the routed time. The fastest rail path runs AirTrain to Jamaica, then a Long Island Rail Road train from Jamaica to Penn Station, a short walk from most Times Square hotels. The CityTicket fare from Jamaica is $5.25 off-peak or $7.25 peak, for totals of $14 off-peak or $16 peak including the AirTrain fare. The cheaper rail path runs AirTrain to Jamaica and the subway from Sutphin Blvd-Archer Av-JFK Airport station to 42 St-Port Authority, the stop the MTA names for Times Square, for $11.75 including the AirTrain fare for most riders: the $8.75 AirTrain fare plus a $3.00 subway ride. The guide to which train to take from JFK Airport to Manhattan covers the rail choice, and the guide to how much the JFK AirTrain costs carries the fare detail.
A yellow taxi between JFK and Manhattan runs on the $70 flat fare in either direction, plus the $2.00 airport access fee on pickup, the $1.00 Improvement Surcharge, the $2.50 New York State Congestion Surcharge for trips touching Manhattan south of 96th Street, the 75-cent MTA Congestion Pricing toll for Manhattan at or below 60th Street, and the $0.50 MTA State Surcharge, which applies only to trips starting in New York City and ending in New York City, Dutchess, Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, Suffolk, or Westchester — a JFK to Times Square trip starts in New York City at JFK and ends in New York City, so the start test passes — for a total of $76.75 before tolls and tip, or $81.75 with the $5.00 weekday rush-hour surcharge from 4 PM to 8 PM. The JetBlack JFK to Manhattan economy flat is $65 for the car. The taxi and the booked car both deliver the traveler to the hotel door; the rail paths deliver the traveler to Penn Station or 42nd Street with a last-block walk and the luggage carried through it.
From LaGuardia: the shortest leg, the cheapest path
LaGuardia is the convenience winner for a Times Square hotel, and the margin is not close: 9.2 miles and 19 minutes of no-traffic driving, roughly half the JFK distance. The cheapest path is the LaGuardia Link Q70, a free bus running nonstop from Terminals B and C to the subway in Jackson Heights every 8 to 10 minutes, taking about 15 minutes in typical traffic, with luggage racks on board — then a $3.00 subway ride, for a $3.00 total. The M60-SBS also runs from LaGuardia to Manhattan for $3.00. LaGuardia has three terminals: Terminal A, historically the Marine Air Terminal, serving Modern Aviation; Terminal B serving Air Canada, American, Frontier, JetBlue, Porter, Southwest, and United; and Terminal C operated by Delta. Confirm the terminal with the airline, because the bus pickup point follows the terminal. The guide to getting to LaGuardia Airport using public transportation covers the transit side in full.
A taxi from LaGuardia is metered, not flat: trips to and from LaGuardia are charged the standard metered fare plus a $5.00 surcharge and all other applicable surcharges, with the $2.00 airport access fee on pickup, plus tolls and tip — no LaGuardia taxi total is stated here, because a metered fare has no honest total before the trip. The short drive keeps the meter down, which is part of why LaGuardia wins on convenience: the cheapest path costs $3.00, the taxi meter runs the shortest distance of the three airports, and the booked car covers the fewest miles. For a traveler who can choose the airport, LaGuardia is the answer; for a traveler already booked into JFK or Newark, the sections above and below give the best path from each.
Ready to Book Your Airport Car Service?
From Newark: a strong train, the priciest transit trip
The Newark Airport to Times Square leg is 16.2 miles and 31 minutes of no-traffic driving — shorter than the JFK drive, but the transit trip is the priciest of the three, because the through ticket costs more than either rival fare. An NJ Transit ticket from Newark Airport to New York Penn Station costs $17.25 for an adult including the AirTrain fare, with about 30 minutes on the train, plus the AirTrain ride from the terminal to the airport station and the platform change there. The AirTrain fee on its own is $8.75 per person, included in an NJ Transit or Amtrak through ticket. During construction, the link to the train station is sometimes replaced by shuttle buses, so check current AirTrain status before travel, and allow the extra change in the plan. From Penn Station, the hotel near Times Square is a short walk north — the same last block as the JFK rail path, with the same luggage carried through it.
A Newark taxi to Manhattan runs on Port Authority estimated fares by zone, and a Times Square hotel falls in Zone 2, W 14th St to W 50th St, at $65. On top of the zone fare come the $2.00 airport access fee, a $10 surcharge on trips to New York State during rush hours — weekdays 6 to 10 AM and 3 to 8 PM, weekends noon to 9 PM — plus tolls, congestion pricing, and tip, with additional fees of $6.75 to $15.75. A weekday 5 PM taxi to a Times Square hotel therefore starts at $77 before tolls, congestion pricing, and tip: the $65 zone fare plus the $2.00 access fee plus the $10 rush-hour surcharge. The $5.00 East Side charge does not apply to a Times Square hotel, because it covers East Side destinations between Battery Park and 145th St. The guide to current taxi rates in New York City carries the New York side of the taxi picture, and the guide to whether cab fares in NYC are regulated explains the regulation behind the fares.
The hotel factor: the last block decides convenience
Convenience is not the fare and not the moving time; it is the whole trip including the last block. A Times Square hotel sits within a short walk of Penn Station and of 42 St-Port Authority, which is why the rail paths rank well despite the walk — but the walk is still a walk, with suitcases, through the busiest sidewalks in the city, and in rain or after midnight it stops feeling short. A shared shuttle splits the difference: as an example, GO Airlink NYC publishes shared-ride fares per person of $32.60 from LaGuardia, $34.46 from JFK, and $39.06 from Newark, with the shuttle making stops along the way, so the trip runs longer than a direct car. A booked car removes the last block entirely: the traveler is dropped at the hotel entrance, the bags stay in one vehicle, and the arrival time is the only variable. On the JFK leg, the Long Island Rail Road option from Jamaica to Penn Station beats the subway on speed and loses on luggage handling. For a solo traveler with one bag in daylight, the transit paths win. For a party, a family with cases, or an arrival after midnight, the car wins, and the airport ranking matters less than the door-to-door certainty.
Booking, cancellation, and special needs
Book the car before the flight, with the hotel name and address, the flight number, the terminal, and the passenger and luggage counts in the first request, and get the pickup time, the meeting point, and the total in writing. Cancellation is free before confirmation; cancelling after confirmation costs $31 in total: $25 plus $5 in fees plus a $1 technology fee. The guide to whether you can cancel or reschedule a car service covers changes in more detail. Child seats cost about $35 per seat for a fee, confirmed at booking, and wheelchair-accessible vehicles are provided on request. The JetBlack fleet page states the vehicle classes, and the guide to how a car service works explains the dispatch model. Whichever airport the flight uses, the convenience rule is the same: price the whole trip to the hotel door, count the changes, carry the luggage question through every option, and choose the path whose worst case is still acceptable.
Questions travelers ask
What is the most convenient airport for a hotel near Times Square?
LaGuardia, on distance and price: 9.2 miles and 19 minutes of no-traffic driving, with a free bus plus a $3.00 subway ride for a $3.00 total. JFK offers a direct rail path to Midtown, and Newark’s train is strong but costs the most.
What is the cheapest way from JFK to a Times Square hotel?
AirTrain plus subway for $11.75 including the AirTrain fare for most riders: the $8.75 AirTrain fare plus a $3.00 subway ride from Sutphin Blvd-Archer Av-JFK Airport station to 42 St-Port Authority, the stop the MTA names for Times Square.
What is the fastest rail path from JFK to Times Square?
Take AirTrain to Jamaica, then a Long Island Rail Road train from Jamaica to Penn Station, and walk to the hotel. The totals are $14 off-peak or $16 peak including the AirTrain fare.
How do I get from Newark Airport to a Times Square hotel?
An NJ Transit ticket from Newark Airport to New York Penn Station costs $17.25 including the AirTrain fare, with about 30 minutes on the train plus the AirTrain ride and the platform change. A Newark taxi to a Times Square hotel falls in Zone 2 at $65, plus the $2.00 access fee, rush-hour surcharge, tolls, and tip. Check current AirTrain status before travel.
Is a booked car or a taxi better for a Times Square hotel?
Both deliver the traveler to the hotel door. A yellow taxi from JFK runs on the $70 flat fare for a total of $76.75 before tolls and tip, or $81.75 at weekday rush hour, while the JetBlack JFK to Manhattan economy flat is $65 for the car. The booked car settles the total and the meeting point before the trip; the taxi needs no booking.
Sources
- OSRM demo server route queries, November 15, 2026: JFK to Times Square 18.1 miles and 32 minutes with no traffic, LaGuardia to Times Square 9.2 miles and 19 minutes with no traffic, Newark Airport to Times Square 16.2 miles and 31 minutes with no traffic
- MTA, How to get to Manhattan from JFK Airport: subway plus AirTrain total $11.75 including the AirTrain fare, AirTrain fare $8.75, subway ride $3.00, 42 St-Port Authority as the stop for Times Square, CityTicket plus AirTrain totals $14 off-peak and $16 peak including the AirTrain fare, accessed November 15, 2026
- New York City Taxi and Limousine Commission, Taxi Fare: $70 flat fare between Manhattan and JFK in either direction, $2.00 airport access fee for pickup only, $1.00 Improvement Surcharge, $2.50 New York State Congestion Surcharge south of 96th Street, 75-cent MTA Congestion Pricing toll at or below 60th Street, $0.50 MTA State Surcharge applying only to trips starting in New York City and ending in New York City, Dutchess, Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Rockland, Suffolk, or Westchester, $5.00 rush-hour surcharge weekdays 4 PM to 8 PM, LaGuardia metered fare plus $5.00 surcharge, accessed November 15, 2026
- MTA, Getting to Manhattan from LaGuardia Airport: LaGuardia Link Q70 free bus every 8 to 10 minutes, about 15 minutes to Jackson Heights, subway fare $3.00, M60-SBS to Manhattan $3.00, accessed November 15, 2026
- Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, LaGuardia Airport terminal information page: Terminal A as the Marine Air Terminal serving Modern Aviation, Terminal B serving Air Canada, American, Frontier, JetBlue, Porter, Southwest, and United, Terminal C operated by Delta, accessed November 15, 2026
- Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Newark Taxi Service page: Manhattan zone estimated fares $60, $65, $70, $75, and $80, Zone 2 W 14th St to W 50th St at $65, $2.00 airport access fee, $10 rush-hour surcharge to New York State, $5.00 East Side charge, additional fees $6.75 to $15.75, accessed November 15, 2026
- NJ Transit airport page and Port Authority public transportation page, as restated by dated secondary guides checked October 19 to November 1, 2026: NJ Transit ticket Newark Airport to New York Penn Station $17.25 including the AirTrain fare, about 30 minutes on the train, AirTrain fee $8.75 on its own, construction shuttle-bus substitution sometimes in effect
- GO Airlink NYC, Airport Shuttle to Manhattan Hotels: shared-ride fares per person $32.60 from LaGuardia, $34.46 from JFK, $39.06 from Newark, shared trips run longer because of stops, accessed November 15, 2026
- JetBlack Transportation, owner-confirmed service facts: JFK to Manhattan economy flat $65, cancellation free before confirmation and $31 total after confirmation with $25 plus $5 in fees plus a $1 technology fee, child seats about $35 per seat for a fee, wheelchair-accessible vehicles provided, dispatch 24/7, since 2010, confirmed October 26, 2026, accessed November 15, 2026
JetBlack Transportation · 34 W 34th St, New York, NY 10001 · +1-646-214-4828 · Fares and schedules verified November 2026 and subject to change — confirm your quote and pickup time in writing before travel