There is no single scheduled shuttle service from Newark Liberty International Airport to JFK with one published timetable to quote, because no operator runs a fixed Newark-to-JFK shuttle on a single route and schedule. The reliable options are a booked car, the transit chain, and a shared-ride operator’s own service, and any shuttle that claims a fixed EWR-to-JFK timetable should be checked against its own booking for your date before you rely on it.

The options, ranked
By booked car: door to door, terminal to terminal, roughly 1 hour clear and 1 hour 30 minutes or more in traffic, with the total fixed in writing before travel, the best choice with luggage or on a tight connection. By transit: AirTrain Newark to Newark Liberty International Airport Station, NJ Transit to New York Penn Station, then subway or Long Island Rail Road to Jamaica and AirTrain JFK to the terminals, roughly 2 hours to 2 hours 30 minutes in total including connections, and the cheapest option for one person travelling light.
By shared-ride operator: a shared van or car that picks up at a window and may stop for other passengers, priced per person or per vehicle depending on the operator, with its own pickup points and timetable printed on its booking. A shared service that does not name its pickup window and timetable for your date has not actually confirmed a ride.
What not to assume
Do not assume a shuttle runs on your date, from your terminal, or at the hour you need, because shared services change with demand and season. Do not borrow a Manhattan fare for this run: neither end is Manhattan, and the NJ Transit rail fare to Penn Station, $17.25 in total including the $8.75 AirTrain fee, is only one leg of the transit chain, not the whole journey.

