There is no single scheduled shuttle that runs airport-to-airport between JFK and Newark Liberty — no bus with a fixed timetable that you can simply turn up and board for a JFK to Newark trip. What exists instead is a choice of three things: a shared-ride van or car booked in advance, a private booked car, or a public-transit chain. Anyone selling you a “JFK to Newark shuttle” ticket without a named operator, a pickup point, and a departure time is selling a promise, not a product.
The honest answer depends on what you value. The transit chain is cheapest and runs all day; the booked car is fastest and simplest with luggage; a shared ride sits in between on price but only works if you book it in advance and accept other passengers and waiting time. Plan on at least 90 minutes for the transfer and two hours to be comfortable, whatever mode you choose.

The transit chain, step by step
AirTrain JFK at $8.75 to Jamaica, then the Long Island Rail Road or subway into Manhattan, then NJ Transit from New York Penn Station to Newark Liberty International Airport station, then the airport AirTrain to your terminal. Allow roughly 2 hours to 2 hours 30 minutes door to door and about $25 to $30 in fares, depending on the rail choices. It is the cheapest way, and it runs through the day and evening — but with heavy luggage and a tight connection it is hard work.
Check the rail timetables for your travel time: late-night and early-morning frequencies are thinner, and a missed connection at Penn Station can add 30 minutes. If your connection is under two hours, transit is not the safe choice.
Ready to Book Your JFK to Newark Ride?
Shared rides and booked cars
Shared-ride airport vans and cars can be booked in advance through the operator or a booking platform, with a pickup window rather than a fixed departure; the fare is quoted per person and depends on the operator, so no single published shuttle fare exists for this route. A private booked car covers the roughly 35-mile drive in about 45 to 75 minutes depending on traffic, and JetBlack quotes such a trip per trip in writing — give both terminals, both flight numbers, and the exact pickup point at booking. Cancellation is free before confirmation; after confirmation the total is $31 ($25 + $5 + $1).

